Sometimes you win. Sometimes you lose. Sometimes you get snubbed by the GRAMMYs.
Noah Kahan’s album The Great Divide is one of the best of the year. Period.
It’s sold hundreds of thousands of copies, has been streamed millions of times, and is selling out stadiums across the world.
The Great Divide did not get nominated for Album of the Year at the GRAMMYs. This was a surprise to many, myself included.
Playing for a sold-out crowd in London the night after the announcement, Kahan said the following on stage through teary eyes:
“I’ve been feeling sh*tty, and I’m happy that I feel sh*tty because it means that I cared about something and let myself believe in things which is more than I’ve done for myself in a long time.”
It’s gutting when you want something that is out of your control and you don’t get it. Anyone who says just let it slide is being disingenuous. At the same time, you cannot hitch your self-worth or the worth of the work to an object that will gather dust on a shelf.
Do you know what The Beach Boys, Tupac Shakur, Queen, and Jimi Hendrix all have in common?
They’ve never won a competitive GRAMMY. Legacy and impact are not trophies decided by a selection committee. They are the ripple you make through what you create and share, and how you live your life.
There’s nothing wrong with wanting to have good work recognized and feeling gutted when it’s not. But the recognition isn’t the thing. The work is the thing.
In London, Kahan continued: “I’m happy that I haven’t gotten exactly what I thought I wanted, because it’s going to require me to remember where my self-worth has to come from, and it’s got to be from within me somewhere. I know I’ll find it. I know I’ll find it.”
I love this man. We have a lot in common, including pretty bad OCD, a deep desire to communicate feelings through words, and a commitment to craft.
He embodies everything that I write about, and right now in particular, he’s living a central idea in my latest book:
“Caring is cool. Nonchalance is a cop out. Pour your heart and soul into what you love, even if it may break your heart. Feel it. Give your all. Give a damn.
When you hold yourself back because you fear failure or looking “uncool,” you sacrifice growth and potential (and mastery and fulfillment and richness and love and all the other good stuff in life) for short-term safety and comfort.
It’s a trap. Get over it.
The things that you care about are the things that break your heart are the things that fill your life with meaning and joy.
The world doesn’t need more mediocrity or going through the motions. The world needs more people putting themselves out there and giving it their all. The world needs more people who have the guts to care. Try hard and give a damn.
The best athletes care deeply.
The best artists care deeply.
The best leaders care deeply.
The best coaches care deeply.
The best teachers care deeply.
The best doctors care deeply.
The best writers care deeply.
The best scientists care deeply.
The best parents care deeply.Caring deeply is the cost of admission to a big and textured life.
Fear and insecurity are part of human nature. You can either go through the motions and be superficially cool (but actually boring). Or you can step into the arena, lay it on the line, care deeply, make yourself vulnerable, and fully live your one and only life.”
Noah Kahan he is not scared to lay it on the line. He cares deeply. He makes himself vulnerable. He uses that vulnerability to connect with others and to pour himself into what he does. He’s a great role-model. I wish I could give him a huge hug.
This stuff isn’t just hard for Kahan it’s hard for all of us. It’s much easier to talk about not hitching yourself to external validation than it is to actually do it. Praise, recognition, and rewards are powerful drugs, especially when it validates work you’ve poured your everything into, work that is a reflection of your very essence.
I was discussing this the other day with a musician who has won multiple GRAMMYs, and she told me Yup, disconnecting yourself [from the external validation] is the most difficult thing to do, but also the most important. We don’t control what other people do or say. It’s humbling and one has to eat the humble pie sometimes.
I wish it weren’t so, and I’m a bit ashamed to admit this, but my mood can absolutely be influenced by a strong sales week or a weak sales week for my books. I’ve resigned myself to this just being the way it is. I don’t think the goal is not to feel these things. I think the goal is to not let these feelings take us away from living our best lives, doing our best work, and having our best relationships.
You can absolve yourself of caring. (Not good.) You can go on a crazy emotional roller coaster where you’re pushed and pulled by things that are outside of your control. (Also not good.) Or you can give your all, work to build an identity and sense of self-worth that comes from within, acknowledge that you’re a human and will still feel highs and lows, let these highs and lows move through you, and keep on keeping on.
Perhaps the best thing to do when you experience a massive disappointment? Go to the people in your life who matter to you most, and go to the work itself. It’s exactly what Kahan did by taking the stage in London just 24 hours after his heartbreak.
“Life goes on,” says Kahan.
It doesn’t make it easy in the moment, but there’s at least some consolation knowing that he’s right.
It’s better to care deeply and fall short than it is not to care and hold back.
The things that you care about are the things that break your heart are the things that fill your life with meaning and joy.
Thanks for reading. Please share this post with someone who think would enjoy it.
And if you find this sort of thing resonant, check out the book. I think you’ll love it: https://bit.ly/TheWayOfExcellence





Brad- thanks for sharing this story and Noah Kahan‘a music, absolutely beautiful.
Your point about outside validation is so relevant. All of us are susceptible. Guarding AND protecting your personal identity are absolutely essential, especially in this materialistic and IG reel based world
Nonchalance is armor. That's how I see it in my work.
Acting like you don't care is the nervous system protecting you from the drop. If you never fully want it, it can't fully hurt you. The cost is you never fully get to live it either.
What Kahan did on that stage is the rarer skill. Not "don't feel it." Feel it all the way through, in front of people, and still show up the next night. That's capacity, and it can be trained.
Years in enterprise sales taught me that caring too visibly was a liability. Unlearning that has been some of the best work of my life.
For anyone sitting in a fresh no right now: https://paigerothschild.substack.com/p/what-you-didnt-get-might-have-destroyed